I have been thinking about what it takes to create true character development after discussions about recent movies and I know of two characters that are perfect examples. This post is about Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy and the Captain America trilogy. It is amazing how similar the beat patterns in the movies, but that is what makes them excellent trilogies. Note that I am not trying to pit them against one another. I enjoy both trilogies equally.
Character Development the right way
A character goes through true development when the audience can understand their motivation. Batman is driven by the loss of his parents, which drives him to eradicate crime. Captain America is driven by the desire to stop the Nazi’s and protect the little guy from bullies. Both Batman and Captain America are taken to the brink, mentally and physically, in their journeys. Both characters grow and change throughout the course of their respective trilogies and you are able to see their perspective change. This is the definition of character development. Characters who are one dimensional are good for the short term, but is never able to capture a monumental spark.
How are the trilogies similar?
Consider the following:
- Bruce Wayne and Steve Rogers faces tragedy that changes them fundamentally
- They both train to become who they are destined to be. Bruce joins the League of Shadows and Steve joins the Army
- They create symbols to embody their mission.
- They undertake huge sacrifices for betterment of others
- Their beliefs are questioned by their opposite, The Joker and Winter Soldier respectively.
- They realize that their sacrifices ultimately meant nothing
- They give up their symbols
Lessons learned from these movies
Christopher Nolan took major risks in his trilogy of Batman. It is not often that we see a Batman that is flawed and making mistakes, but that was a part of the trilogy. Bruce did not want the burden of being Batman forever. He knew he was going to give up the mantle once his heir presented himself. Batman is not typically portrayed as vulnerable, but we accepted it without question in this trilogy.
Captain America went from being the star-spangled hero, to the destroyer of SHIELD and ultimately a war criminal. It is true that his story is part of a larger narrative; however, his trilogy is the best of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Risks were taken to deconstruct his character in such a way that would make him vulnerable as well.
It is no surprise that The Dark Knight and Captain America: The Winter Soldier are both viewed as excellent sequels and overall films. The key is not to be afraid to explore the characters from all aspects. They must grow mentally and physically. Also, it is important to put the right opponent in front of them to make things meaningful. Just because a villain is cool in one medium does not mean it works in others, Im looking at you venom! My suggestion for anyone wondering what it means to have great character development is to study these movies.